How bullying + cowardice = tolerance of hate

Southern Poverty Law Center: A City Held Hostage

“They have used their constitutional rights,” Topeka Mayor Joan Wagnon says of Phelps and his followers, “to bully this town into submission.”

For 10 years, Phelps and his Westboro Baptists — a congregation almost entirely composed of his extended family — have waged a battle against lesbians, gays and a whole host of other perceived enemies.

They have used daily pickets, an array of intimidating tactics, scores of lawsuits and a veritable flood of faxes that are so filled with slurs and sex that they rival the product of the most prolific professional pornographer.

They run America’s most infamous anti-homosexual web site, In the process, even as they made life miserable for their enemies, Fred Phelps and his followers have created a niche for themselves in Topeka…

…And Suzanne James, who recently resigned after eight years in the Shawnee County District Attorney’s office as director of victim services, says Phelps’s opposition to homosexuality obscures a deeper purpose — promoting himself and hurting others.

“I’m so tired of people calling him an ‘anti-gay activist’,” James told the Report. “He’s not an anti-gay activist. He’s a human abuse machine.”

The most striking aspect of Westboro Baptist pickets is the relentlessly personal nature of their taunts. Their targets are only sometimes homosexuals; as often as not, they are simply people who somehow crossed the Phelpses, often unintentionally…

…For years, economic growth in Topeka has been negligible — a dilemma Westboro Baptist has clearly helped to exacerbate. But the Topeka Convention and Visitor’s Bureau (CVB), which promotes city tourism and economic development, has declined to investigate the problem.

According to Randy Austin and Betty Simecka, who are both former CVB presidents, that is because of fear of Phelps’ harassment. Frustrated, Simecka and another former CVB employee got together privately to document the effect of Phelps and his church on convention business.

They found five instances where lost conventions could be directly attributed to WBC’S activities. In one case, a potential convention client was touring the city with a CVB official when they drove by a Phelps picket. “The lady [client] was hysterical and got down on the floor of the car,” the Simecka report said. “They will not ever consider Topeka for a meeting ‘as long as the Phelps group has a presence.'”

The estimated loss in these cases alone was $16.5 million…

We only need to look at the growing power of hate groups worldwide to realize that Topeka is not unique


About marypmadigan

Writer/photographer (profession), foreign policy wonk (hobby).
This entry was posted in domestic politics. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to How bullying + cowardice = tolerance of hate

  1. Infidel753 says:

    I’ve long wondered what to make of Phelps’s operation. It does have all the outward signs of a childish attention-getting device, and its tactics are flagrantly counterproductive from the viewpoint of what they supposedly seek to accomplish (getting people to condemn homosexuals, apparently). On the other hand, they could make a strong case that they are simply obeying the Bible (or rather a few selected bits of it), in which case it doesn’t need to make sense. Of course either of these interpretations is consistent with some degree of mental illness.

    In practical terms, though, it’s the behavior and its effects that are important, not the underlying motive.

    It’s hard to see what Topeka can legitimately do about the problem. Any tactic to rein in Phelps’s activities could just as easily be used against the free speech of any unpopular group anywhere that conventiongoers, etc. are turned off by.

  2. marypmadigan says:

    It’s hard to see what Topeka can legitimately do about the problem.

    I don’t know enough about Phelps to have found his weaknesses, but I’d assume that he’d be intimidated by the things he uses to intimidate others. Bullies are too self-centered to understand the motivation of other people, so they assume that the things that terrify them also terrify others.

    Phelps tactics are used by other hate groups all over the Muslim world. If we can’t see what the people of Topeka can do about a raging zealot who uses non-violent methods to encourage tolerance of his beliefs, then what can we expect people to do to fight groups like the Muslim Brotherhood?

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s